New Jersey Sportsbooks Recouped Big Losses During NFL Playoffs

Michael Savio
By: Michael Savio
02/19/2025
Sports Betting
Photo by Spc. Brandon C. Dyer, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Photo by Spc. Brandon C. Dyer, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Key Takeaways

  • The sports betting dipped in January, despite a spike in gross revenue
  • Favored teams dominated during the NFL playoffs
  • FanDuel led all online sportsbooks for the month, but DraftKings saw the most growth

The NFL season was rough for New Jersey sportsbooks, but the playoffs have provided some relief.

In January, the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement reported a 94.6% year-over-year spike in gross revenue for sportsbooks. This came despite the betting handle decreasing by over 30% from 2024 and 5% compared to December. Sportsbooks won more bets, helping them recoup losses suffered during a rough NFL season.

The spike in gross revenue led to the state receiving almost $18 million in tax revenue.

NFL Favorites Dominate Playoffs

Sportsbooks went into the NFL playoffs disappointed by the results from the regular season. Favored teams won at the highest rate in over 20 years, leading to more wins for bettors. Many of those bettors were placing parlays, leading to bigger payouts.

Once the playoffs started, things went very differently. Favored teams dominated, leading to a big bump in revenue for sportsbooks. This has helped operators compensate for losses suffered during the regular season, kicking off 2025 with a bang.

Is the New Jersey Market Shrinking?

While the massive spike in gross revenue is an excellent sign for sportsbooks, the drop in handle is curious. It is hard to believe that a market like New Jersey would be shrinking, but there is no denying January’s numbers.

Other states may begin to report their numbers for the month, and we may get a better picture. The NFL playoffs will likely increase gross revenue, but the handles will vary. The historic season may have led more bettors to cash out their winnings and skip the playoffs, but we won’t know until more numbers are in.

FanDuel Continues to Lead the Way

FanDuel Sportsbooks once again led all New Jersey online operators in January. While the operator enjoyed its best month of the NFL season, it was still short of its numbers from January 2024.

DraftKings finished behind rival FanDuel but saw the most significant revenue gains of any operator compared to December. The operator generated over $36 million in revenue in January. BetMGM finished a distant third with $7.7 million in revenue.

The most notable result came from Fanatics, which finished just behind BetMGM. The operator continues to expand in the US and is beginning to catch and surpass BetMGM in several markets. While it remains far behind FanDuel and DraftKings, more bettors are switching to Fanatics.

Michael Savio covers the US online casino industry, giving readers insights and information they won’t find anywhere else. He has followed the retail industry since his time living in Las Vegas and has continued to do so as the online industry has taken off. Michael covers everything from online casino reviews to industry news, making him one of the most trusted insiders in the business. Check out Michael’s latest articles at casinos.com to see what he has to offer!